Community, diversity and the public good

By -

I'm intending to go along to this event and decided I would set out my thoughts on the questions put so I will hopefully be able to give some cogent answers. As always as a Humanist I have to admit that I can be wrong and would therefore welcome comments below.

The Commission on Religion and Belief in British Public Life: community, diversity and the public good

12 March 2014, 3.30-5.30pm

The commission asks:

What are the foundations of a democratic and diverse nation?
How is community identity formed in a multi-faith society?
Should the freedom of religious expression be limited?
How should religion and belief be taught in state schools?
What lessons can Leicester share about interfaith dialogue and action?

What are the foundations of a democratic and diverse nation?

I think the word liberal is missing here. Our liberties, established in the Magna Carta, Bill of Rights 1689 and the Human Rights Act, limit the power of the state over the individual and in my view precede and take precedence over democracy. These include the rule of law, free speech, freedom of thought and religion together with freedom of association.

The power of democratic government has to be limited in order to protect the individual. Hitler was supported by a majority and this was a major motivation behind the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

A diverse nation is made up of diverse individuals.

How is community identity formed in a multi-faith society?

Diverse individuals should result in a diverse society. In a healthy society we belong to multiple communities. Religion cannot be the base for a sustainable society if it attempts to monopolise community.

A Sikh 
  • attending the gurdwara 
  • going to Sikh schools
  • working for Sikh businesses
  • playing sport with other Sikhs
  • living in a Sikh area of a city 
  • with only Sikh friends
may be a member of a multi-faith society, but it is also an apartheid society (even if voluntary) and highly schismatic.

In a plural and inclusive society (which is what I believe must be our ambition) a Sikh might 
  • attend the gurdwara every week 
  • go to a community school attended by those of many religions and none
  • work for a business where your religion is irrelevant
  • play sport for any club that suits
  • live in whatever part of the city suits his/her lifestyle
  • have friends of multiple religions and beliefs.
 I submit that this results in strong communities and a strong society.

Should the freedom of religious expression be limited?

No more than for free speech. Shouting “Fire” in a theater when there is no fire should be illegal. Inciting violence should be illegal. Otherwise we have to accept that free speech means that we have to be prepared to be offended and not react. Without the ability to offend, the term free speech is meaningless.

Accusing your opponent of causing you offence is a tactic, which allows you to avoid putting your own case, or pointing out the other’s flaws.

How should religion and belief be taught in state schools?

Comparative religion should be taught in state schools along side philosophy and critical thinking. Children should understand the history of religious beliefs and the main beliefs of those following the major religions, in order that they can relate to followers and avoid causing unintended offence.

The inculcation of religion should be the sole prerogative of parents and religious organisations.

What lessons can Leicester share about interfaith dialogue and action?

The civil authority must be agnostic and neutral with regard to religion (secular) and encourage dialogue between all communities (which includes all the groups that make up society).

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Hindu Council UK objects to talk on "Hinduism: A Wretched, Immoral Compass"

By -
Image
The Society hosted a talk on the caste system on 3rd December 2023. Before the talk on 19th November the Secretary of the Society received the following email - We write to express our deep concern and offense regarding the title of an event scheduled to take place at your venue, titled "Hinduism: Wretched Immoral Compass." It has come to our attention that such a choice of words is not only derogatory but also appears to be anti-Hinduism.   Hinduism, a faith with a rich history spanning thousands of years and followed by over one billion people worldwide, deserves respect and understanding. Using such inflammatory language seems designed to appeal and incite hatred towards Hindus, who are one of the largest and most peaceful communities globally. As a secular society, we believe it is your responsibility to avoid language that may be offensive or disrespectful towards any faith.   We urge you to consider the implications of this event title and whether it aligns with t
Read more

A Last Message from Frank Friedmann

By -
From Frank   You'll have heard that I'm not well.  Here's an update about how we are. And I'll start with me, which I know isn't really polite, but here goes.   It's cancer of the gall bladder, and it's spread to other organs making it inoperable.  And because chemo carries a high risk of blood clots (which I didn't know about before) alongside all the other side effects, that's ruled out because of the stent plumbing in my heart.  So, I'm not going to get better.  In spite of it all, I'm in good spirits - happy in fact.   This is of course most devastating for Eleanor - we came here to an area we didn't know at all for life's last big adventure, and we've grown to love with the diverse land-, river- and seascapes around and across Morecambe Bay and the Forest of Bowland.  The community here isn't perfect but mostly supportive and interesting, and we have both got stuck in with playing an active part in hel
Read more

A Message of Thanks from the Hon. Treasurer

By -
I would like to give thanks to humanity and in particular the Neuro Trauma team at Queens Medical Centre, Nottingham, for saving my life. On the morning of Monday 27th May my wife discovered me unconscious on the bathroom floor. The emergency services took me down to Leicester A&E where a brain scan showed that blood had been leaking from a vein into my right cranium, putting pressure on the brain. The scan was sent through to the Neuro Trauma team at Queens Medical Centre in Nottingham who said they needed to operate urgently. I was rushed to Nottingham and on Monday night operated on to remove the blood causing the problems and seal the vein.  I regained consciousness Tuesday morning with all my faculties (as far as I can tell). The surgeons assure me that I should be back to normal in a month or two. Without the human endeavour of millions of people that develop and support our communication and transport systems and in particular the ability to scan the brain, my treatment woul
Read more